At American Pie, the pizza starts with fresh dough that’s hand-tossed, lightly charred, and layered with just the right amount of sauce and cheese, golden and gooey, just the way you like it. Whether you go classic cheese, pepperoni, or build your own with all the toppings, there’s something for everyone at the table.Â
Big portions, fast service, and that unmistakable fresh-from-the-oven flavor make this spot a top pick for post-beach dinners and casual Outer Banks nights.
Homemade Ice Cream That Hits the Sweet Spot
This is not your average ice cream. American Pie churns their ice cream in-house daily, and you can taste the difference from the very first bite. It’s creamy, rich, and full of flavor. With a rotating lineup of favorites like Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl, Mint Chocolate Chip, and more, there’s always something new to try.
Whether you’re cooling off after a long beach day or just want a late-night cone, this is the sweet treat your Outer Banks trip needs.
Come Hungry, There’s More Than Just Pizza
While their pizza and homemade ice cream might draw you in, the rest of the menu at American Pie is just as impressive. From burgers and hand-breaded chicken baskets to po’ boys, hot subs, and crisp salads, every item is prepared with the same attention to quality and flavor.
Whether you’re craving something hearty or something light, the menu offers a variety of satisfying options that make American Pie a go-to for families, groups, and hungry beachgoers alike.
Family-Owned, Community-Loved
This isn’t some big franchise with a corporate playbook. American Pie is owned and operated by a local family who’s been part of the Outer Banks community for decades. It’s that hands-on care and attention that keeps people coming back, summer after summer, slice after slice.
Must-Try Favorites from the Menu at American Pie in Kill Devil Hills
Not sure where to start? These are the ones people keep coming back for:
- Pizza Margarita – Fresh and simple, this pie features roasted garlic, sliced tomatoes, whole mozzarella, and a sprinkle of basil for a light yet flavorful bite.
- Weed Eater Pizza – A perfect pick for veggie lovers, this pizza is loaded with mushrooms, black olives, onions, and green peppers.
- The Meaty Pizza – A meat lover’s favorite, topped with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and a touch of garlic for bold, savory flavor.
- Fried Shrimp Po’ Boy – Served on a toasted 8″ sub roll with crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, and a sweet chili mayo for the perfect finishing touch.
- Any flavor of their homemade ice cream, with a hand-made waffle cone!
