Our menu changes frequently.
Price and selection will vary.
Experience the culinary brilliance of renowned restaurateur Tommy Karole at his latest venture, The Pony and the Boat Comfort Kitchen. Known for his successful restaurants in the northern Outer Banks, including the beloved Paper Canoe in Duck, Karole now brings his exceptional hospitality and innovative cuisine to this casually chic eatery located at milepost 4.5 on the Bypass in Kitty Hawk.
Inspired by the Lyle Lovett song “If I Had a Boat,” The Pony and the Boat offers a fresh and delightful twist on classic comfort food. Imagine your favorite dishes reimagined with the passion and skill of a chef dedicated to sourcing the finest ingredients and exploring imaginative preparations. From mouthwatering renditions of chicken pot pie, fried chicken, and delectable Outer Banks seafood to indulgent pot roast and exceptional Southern-style sides, this Kitty Hawk restaurant caters to everyone’s taste buds, including vegans, vegetarians, and children. It’s comfort food executed to perfection, meant to be savored alongside a glass of wine, an artisanal North Carolina craft brew, a craft cocktail, or even a choice from their extensive selection of bourbons.
Embracing a Friendly Neighborhood Vibe Step into The Pony and the Boat Comfort Kitchen and be greeted by an inviting atmosphere adorned with warm, reclaimed barn wood and wood treated using the traditional Japanese fire-touched method of yakisugi. The main dining area boasts a cathedral ceiling with a mesmerizing inverted row boat suspended above, basking in natural light that pours in from the fireplace. Stainless steel accents, subtle lighting, and soothing blues create a relaxed and modern ambiance in the spacious bar area. Whether you prefer to sit at the bar, cozy up in a private booth, or relax in the expansive main dining room, this Kitty Hawk restaurant caters to groups of all sizes with versatile table configurations.
Visit The Pony and the Boat Comfort Kitchen for an elevated dining experience, where comfort food is reimagined with culinary expertise and served in a welcoming and stylish environment.
