American Pie Pizza Menu


American Pie Menu

Menu items & prices subject to change

Order Online

More American Pie Information >

Welcome to American Pie, the ultimate Pizza destination in Kill Devil Hills, located on the beach road of the beautiful Outer Banks. Conveniently situated at mile post 9.5, across from the Ramada and not too far from Nags Head, our pizzeria is a long-standing favorite in the area. Our hand-tossed pizzas are baked to perfection, always served piping hot. When it comes to Pizza in Kill Devil Hills, American Pie is the place to be.

Whether you prefer to build your own pizza or indulge in our house special, we’ve got you covered. Each pizza is hand-prepared to order with freshly made dough and a wide selection of toppings. Enjoy the flexibility of taking out your pizza or dining in at our cozy establishment. At American Pie Pizza in Kill Devil Hills, we cater to groups of all sizes and specialize in large group pizza orders.

If you’re not in the mood for pizza, don’t worry! American Pie Drive-In offers a diverse menu for take-out orders. Choose from mouthwatering burgers, Po-Boys, chicken baskets, refreshing salads, and our homemade ice cream, which has garnered rave reviews since our opening.

Indulge in our famous OBX Ice Cream, crafted right here at American Pie. Served in homemade waffle cones, our ice cream delights with daily flavor variations and hand-packed pints. You can also enjoy single cones for a quick treat. With countless flavors to choose from, our ice cream is the perfect dessert or refreshing indulgence on a hot summer day.

American Pie is a family-friendly destination where you can come as you are, straight off the beach. Everyone in your group will find a tasty treat to enjoy, with a wide array of flavors available. Make sure to include a visit to American Pie in your Outer Banks vacation plans. We guarantee you’ll be glad you did!

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt