American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream

American Pie – Best Pizza in Kill Devil Hills, NC: This local, family-owned, and operated restaurant has grown to be an Outer Banks favorite. In fact, they were voted best pizza and ice cream in the Taste of the Beach! American Pie sits on Highway 12 in Kill Devil Hills, just walking distance from many hotels, motels, cottages, and of course the beach! The restaurant provides both indoor and outdoor dining.

Although American Pie prides itself on their one-of-a-kind pizza, they offer a variety of items on the menu. Serving hand-tossed NY-style pizza made from scratch. Also featuring and delicious homemade, hand-dipped ice cream and house-made waffle cones — we make it here, it’s the real deal. American Pie uses only premium ingredients with flavors that change daily. Ice cream is sold by the cone or by hand-packed pints. Lunch, dinner, for eat-in or carry-out fun. Whether it’s date night, family night, or just snack time, American Pie is sure to meet your needs! All major credit cards are accepted.